Are We Overmanaging Our Children’s Play?

In trying to make our children’s playtime productive, we may be unwittingly hindering their growth

Share this article

Your young child is happily exploring a cardboard box.

Do you:

a) let them be, or

b) join in and turn it into a learning opportunity – perhaps by asking them to spell “box”?

If you picked the latter, you’re not alone. As parents, many of us feel compelled to make every activity count. But when it comes to play, doing less can give our children more room to learn.

In KPI-driven Singapore, where children’s schedules are easily filled with enrichment classes and other planned activities, unstructured play is becoming harder to access, says Karen Chin, a play pedagogist at Playeum.

Unlike structured play, which takes place within an established activity or set of rules, unstructured play is open-ended and child-led. There is no prescribed result: the child decides what to do with the time, space or materials available.

A cardboard box could become a boat, a car, a house, or something that makes sense only to the child playing with it.

Karen shares that children need both kinds of play. The concern is not that they have too much structured play, but that they may have too few opportunities to play without an adult deciding what that play should look like.

When cycling to tuition counts as play

During our Too Tired Mums live chat at Kiztopia Marina Square, Karen shared an encounter from one of her play sessions that has stayed with her.

In the course of her work facilitating play sessions for children, she’d asked a group of children when they had last played.

While some struggled to answer, one Primary 6 boy eagerly responded: “I cycled to the tuition centre.”

“A few hearts broke in the room,” Karen recalled.

Cycling can, of course, be fun. But the boy’s answer suggested that travelling to and from tuition was one of the few moments in his day that felt like play.

It captures a struggle many of us live with. We want our children to enjoy being children, but we also worry about whether they are learning enough, keeping up or making the best use of their time.

Before long, play starts to need a purpose.

When a cardboard box gets a KPI

My fellow speaker Jill Lim, a mum of two preschoolers, confessed that she has a habit of turning her daughters’ play into a learning opportunity.

When her older daughter turned a cardboard box into a boat, Jill’s instinct was to hand her a marker.

“Write ‘boat’, because you need to learn how to spell,” she recalled telling her.

When the box became a car, that presented another opportunity: “How do we spell ‘car’?”

Many of us have done our own version of this. We ask leading questions, make helpful suggestions or try to improve a game that our child was already perfectly happy playing.

We want to be involved parents, and we want the time we spend with our children to be meaningful. But there’s also value in stepping back to let our kids discover their own version of play.

“Playing on the surface looks like there are no outcomes, no KPIs,” Karen said. “But we’re all very driven by KPIs at work, and we then project it onto our children.”

Play can be productive without producing anything

The irony is that children are already learning through play – even when there is no worksheet, completed craft or newly spelt word to show for it.

When children decide what a cardboard box represents, they are using their imagination and making decisions. When an idea does not work, they have to adapt and try something else. When other children join in, they learn to communicate, negotiate and deal with disagreement.

Unstructured play also allows children to navigate situations without clear instructions or predictable outcomes. And that’s an increasingly valuable ability in a rapidly changing world.

Karen stressed that social-emotional development provides an important foundation for cognitive learning. Skills such as managing emotions, interacting with others and responding to unfamiliar situations support a child’s ability to learn.

In other words, a lack of visible output doesn’t mean nothing productive is happening.

So when should we join our children’s play, and when should we step back? What counts as play as children grow older? And how does playing with our kids shape our relationship with them later?

Watch our Too Tired Mums conversation below.

This Too Tired Mums live chat was recorded at SWW x Kiztopia: Let’s Play!, held in partnership with Kiztopia.

Too Tired Mums is The Singapore Women’s Weekly’s original talk show series that gives motherhood its most honest voice — where real mums open up about the things we don’t always say out loud, reminding us that we’re never truly alone.

Host: Estelle Low
Guests: Karen Chin, Jill Lim
Producer: Maya Eman
Art director: Michelle Lee
Videography and editing: Andrew Goh

Share this article
Join our Village